Posted by: dogstail | November 10, 2007

Good for Pakistan

The General has done it again, his second coup. For a country used to martial law and presidents wearing uniforms the reaction has been startling to say the least. We have these lawyers, judges, educated middle class and chic women dressed in equally fashionable hijabs hurling stones at police and army. In fact in most of the coverage on international TV you see only the intelligentsia of the country taking to the streets. Poor and generally downtrodden types are conspicuous by their absence or have they resigned themselves to their fate, which will remain the same, whoever is in the government?

A cynic that I am would think that the protests are stage managed and meant to give post General mileage to the protesting high heeled guys. But keeping that aside I really admire the zeal with which the educated middle class, the professionals, who would think ten times about getting their hands dirty, people who would carry on with the business trying to ‘Manage’, finding a middle path,  have come out enmass to protest against the General’s high handedness.

Actually General did this at a wrong time. I think Pakistanis have evolved. They got an education, have travelled, are on the net and learnt about the world more than Mullahs would allow them to, right under the noses of the Military-Mullah combine.

Compare this to Indian intelligentsia, educated middle class, Business class and professionals. Comfortably going about the business and even profiting from the rank corruption that is pervading our daily lives. Not a day passes when I do not see an instance of somebody making a quick buck out of somebody else’s misery. We are no better than a dictatorship or maybe a dictatorship of say something like Old Iraq, Cuba or even China is better than the stifling polity that we call democracy. The whole thing has become an ugly symbiosis of sorts. You scratch mine and I’ll Scratch yours.

A doctor who overcharges and over-prescribes is happy to pay a politician or a babu to get his measly clinic certified as a research centre. A businessman who has never paid any taxes is also too happy pay police to lathi charge his own workers. Not to speak of politicians, who it seems were born without souls. Corrupt lawyers, judges, babus, police, even some in the army….where does it all end. When was the last time we saw educated middle class protest against anything other than price rise?

Why should I blame others when I myself belong to the same group?


Responses

  1. Hi, welcome to blogging.

    This is such an honest confession.
    Everyone indulge in corruption.
    Only the threshold of guilt varies. Just enough to get away with, just less than feeling guilty.

    Will we ever be clean? Never.

    It is in our genes to cheat and be dishonest. The ‘human’ attribute that we inherited as we evolved. Survival of the fittest. We cannot stop, it is vital to our survival, the process of evolution.

    Come to think of it, it does set us apart from all other animals.

  2. Yes littleindian. Even those at the bottom of the pile are not an exception. He pays 10 Rs. to local cop but mixes water in milk. He give 900 gms of potato instead of 1 Kg.

    Guilt!! we can always wash off by going to temples, mosques and churches and donating our ‘hard earned’ cash in big gunny sacks.

  3. @littleindian

    well you see its not in our genes… its not the survival of the fittest… what crap are you talking (pls don’t mind my language i went to very bad schools and do not know the politically correct language) coming back pls do not misuse Darwin’s theory of evolution; survival of the fittest to justify corruption… In biology, evolution is the change in the inherited traits of a population from one generation to the next… so both good and bad things are inherited… its up to us what we want give to our progeny… have you ever thought how will it end; how this cycle will end?

  4. @ V
    would you know what sarcasm is?

    And since you insist on being scientific,
    by evolution, I referred to

    the process of natural selection that causes heritable traits that are helpful for survival and reproduction to become more common, and harmful traits to become more rare.
    This occurs because organisms with advantageous traits pass on more copies of these heritable traits to the next generation.

    It has nothing to do with “good” or “bad traits”.

    To call what I wrote crap without knowing the facts, is bad manners. I would suggest you return to your biology books.

    It ofcourse needs some level of intelligence to understand sarcasm. On this, I do not have any suggestions.

  5. @ littleindian

    well it was not sarcasm, its called escape… it was like trying to say let it be, the world is like that what can we do, what can a single person do. the darwinian theory is a theory of convenience to legitimize wrong doings like corruption… why dont you brandish Dushyant Kumar’s lines “kaun kehta hai ki aasman mein ched ho nahi sakta, ek pathar to tabiyat se uchalon yaron… meaning who says you cant penetrate the sky (make the impossible happen), at least make an attempt with full conviction…
    and coming back to good and bad traits, they mean traits which will cause growth or end of a species… so i guess i dont need to explain this point about the end…

  6. There is not point in starting a war. So typical of the subsontinent. Always on a war path.
    It can be genes, it can be culture. Genetically most animals are programmed to be selfish or at the most their selflessness extends to immediate family. They dont feel guilty about snatching food from the others mouth. But the emotion ‘guilt’ probably has not evolved in them.
    We call unusual selfishness ‘corruption’, which may actually be just expressing your deepest animal instincts, because (1) intelligence has not been able to remove the selfishness (2) Our still evolving human nature has infused in some of us sence of guilt.
    Moving back to the topic. Today on CNN some poor pakistanis were actually telling that they are fed up with everybody, they have seen Bhutto, Nawaz and the Army. It is only an option between the colour of the devil.

  7. It is only an option between the colour of the devil.

    well said… you said everything…
    i agree…


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories